SAME
PSI-102DetectionSmoke and Aerosol Measurement Experiment
Objectives
- characterize the size distribution of smoke particulate produced in low-gravity from a variety of overheated spacecraft materials
- obtain this data that could then be used to design the next-generation smoke detectors for space exploration missions
- To make sufficient measurements of smoke from spacecraft fires to enable improved design of future detectors.
- Quantify the sizes that the liquid smoke particulate achieves in low gravity and to relate the droplet size distribution to the smoke generation and smoke transport conditions in the experiment.
- Make measurements of three moments of the particle size distribution for the Μg smoke from several materials found in spacecraft considering the effects of sample temperature, air flow, smoke residence time (near the source) and smoke aging.
- Make measurements of the effect of µg and 1-g on the size distribution of liquid aerosol smokes (using an idealized smoke e.g. DBT) to provide data for numerical model comparison.
- Evaluate the performance in µg of the two existing U.S. spacecraft smoke detector designs for the test conditions.
- Evaluate other smoke detection/sensing devices at NASA’s request for the test materials
The moment method was developed, from which the characteristics of the particle size distribution can be inferred using a minimum number of portable instruments. Samples of materials were heated to temperatures below the ignition point under controlled repeatable sample surface temperatures and air flow conditions. The transport time was simulated by holding the smoke in an aging chamber for times ranging from 10 seconds to 1800 seconds. Smoke particle samples were collected on Transmission Electron Microscope (TEM) grids for post-flight analysis, and smoke properties were measured using particulate aerosol diagnostics that measure different moments of the size distribution.
Conditions
| Parameter | Tested value or range | Unit |
|---|---|---|
| Oxygen | – | % by volume |
| Pressure | – | psi |
| Pressure | – | kPa |
| Airflow | 2 to 10 | cm/s |
| Gravity | Microgravity | |
| Diluents | nitrogen | |
| Fuel phase | Solid | |
| Fuels | cellulose, Kapton, silicone rubber, Teflon, dibutyl-phthalate, Silicone Rubber, Cellulose, Dibutyl Phthalate | |
| Sample geometry | cylinder | |
| Sample size | approximately 3 mm diameter cylinder | as stated |
| Hardware | MSG | |
| Platform | ISS | |
| Years | 2000-2009 |
A dash means the sources do not state the value.
Variables varied
- airflow rates
- pyrolysis temperatures
- smoke aging durations
- sample temperature
- air flow rate
- smoke aging duration
- material
- air flow
- weight loss rate
- aging duration
Variables held fixed
- sample geometry
Sensors
- condensation nuclei counter (P-Trak)
- ionization chamber
- light scattering device (DustTrak)
- Transmission Electron Microscope (TEM)
- space shuttle smoke detector
- ISS smoke detector
- condensation nuclei counter
- light scattering device
- thermal precipitator
- transmission electron microscope
- P-Trak Ultrafine Particle Counter
- DustTrak
- First Alert ionization smoke detector
- STS smoke detector
- Transmission Electron Microscope
- video camera
- pressure transducer
- mass flow controller
Findings (13)
Key findings
The experimental results show that, for the materials tested, a substantial portion of the smoke particles are below 500 nm in diameter.
The smoke transport model demonstrated that mixing dominates the smoke transport and that consequently detection time lags are longer than in normal gravity.
The small diameters for the Kapton and Teflon will make detection of this smoke challenging for light scattering devices, on the other hand the large sizes seen with the lamp wick and silicone would generate very large signals on a light scattering system, suggesting that detection of these particles against the background environment will require a detection system capable of measuring more than one moment of the particle size distribution.
Source: PSI-102 Reports SAME Final Science Report, p. 27; PSI-102 Reports SAME Final Science Report, p. 48
The aging results show substantial increase in the average particle sizes with them rising to over 1 Ιm for the aged silicone diameter of average mass.
The preliminary results from these experiments indicate that substantial differences in the size distributions of the smoke particles are evident for the four materials that were tested.
For the conditions of the SAME experiment, all samples produced significant numbers of sub-micron particulate that are better detected using an ionization smoke detector.
Smoke particulate produced in low-gravity was found to be typically 50% large in count mean diameter than similar conditions in normal gravity.
The resultant sizes were all below 300 nm suggesting that discriminating smoke from spacecraft dust possibly could be achieved by detecting in the sub-micrometer range.
Numerical modeling of smoke transport in the US Lab Module of the ISS predicted that actual detection times can be quite long and strongly dependent on location and the presence of obstructions.
The Comparative Soot Diagnostics (CSD) experiment that flew in the Glovebox on STS-75 demonstrated that the smokes with solid particulates created in microgravity formed longer chains, and aggregated into larger particles than those created in normal Earth gravity.
Source: PSI-102 Science Documents SAME Baseline Concept Description Doc, p. 7
Experience with CSD showed dramatic cases where clearly visible smoke streams were not always detectable by the smoke detectors while invisible smoke streams were readily detected.
Source: PSI-102 Science Documents SAME Baseline Concept Description Doc, p. 11
Overall the detection times were dominated by the circumferential flow, the axial flow from the intermodule ventilation and the smoke source strength.
Source: ISS Destiny Laboratory Smoke Detection Model, p. 1 (DOI)
Ignition
In order to simulate the detection of a pre-fire overheated-material event, samples were heated to temperatures below the ignition point.
Fire safety relevance
tables/PSI-102_Experimental table_SAME.csv
Tests (16)
| Test | Sample | Fuel | Sample geometry | O2 (%) | Pressure (psi) | Airflow (cm/s) | Diluent | Outcome | Spread rate (mm/s) | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| PSI-102-T1 | 23 | Silicone | cylinder | – | – | – | – | No ignition | – | Silicone Initial, Carousel 3, Position 1 |
| PSI-102-T2 | 24 | Silicone | cylinder | – | – | – | – | No ignition | – | Silicone Initial, Carousel 3, Position 2 |
| PSI-102-T3 | 25 | Teflon | cylinder | – | – | – | – | No ignition | – | Teflon Initial, Carousel 3, Position 4 |
| PSI-102-T4 | 26 | Teflon | cylinder | – | – | – | – | No ignition | – | Teflon Initial, Carousel 3, Position 5 |
| PSI-102-T5 | 32 | Lampwick | cylinder | – | – | – | – | No ignition | – | Lampwick Initial, Carousel 4, Position 2 |
| PSI-102-T6 | 33 | Kapton | cylinder | – | – | 2 | – | No ignition | – | Kapton Initial, Carousel 4, Position 6, missed first part of heating, using 2 cm/s |
| PSI-102-T7 | 34 | Lampwick | cylinder | – | – | 2 | – | No ignition | – | Lampwick Initial, Carousel 4, Position 3, using 2 cm/s |
| PSI-102-T8 | 37 | DBP | cylinder | – | – | 8 | – | No ignition | – | DBP Reheat, Carousel 5, Position 6, 8 cm/s |
| PSI-102-T9 | 1 | Teflon | – | – | – | 5 | – | Not stated | – | Weight loss rate: 2 mg/min, Aging Duration: 1 minutes |
| PSI-102-T10 | 2 | Teflon | – | – | – | 5 | – | Not stated | – | Weight loss rate: 1 mg/min, Aging Duration: 1 minutes |
| PSI-102-T11 | 3 | Teflon | – | – | – | 5 | – | Not stated | – | Weight loss rate: 2 mg/min, Aging Duration: 20 minutes |
| PSI-102-T12 | 4 | Teflon | – | – | – | 10 | – | Not stated | – | Weight loss rate: 2 mg/min, Aging Duration: 1 minutes |
| PSI-102-T13 | 5 | Kapton: same conditions as 1-4 | – | – | – | – | – | Not stated | – | – |
| PSI-102-T14 | 6 | Silicone Rubber: same conditions as 1-4 | – | – | – | – | – | Not stated | – | – |
| PSI-102-T15 | 7 | Lampwick: same conditions as 1-4 | – | – | – | – | – | Not stated | – | – |
| PSI-102-T16 | 8 | Dibutyl Phthalate: same conditions as 1-4 | – | – | – | – | – | Not stated | – | – |
Sources (35)
- PSI-102 Experimental table SAME, p. 1
- PSI-102 Reports SAME Final Science Report, p. 1
- PSI-102 Reports SAME Final Science Report, p. 3
- PSI-102 Reports SAME Final Science Report, p. 4
- PSI-102 Reports SAME Final Science Report, p. 20
- PSI-102 Reports SAME Final Science Report, p. 21
- PSI-102 Reports SAME Final Science Report, p. 27
- PSI-102 Reports SAME Final Science Report, p. 29
- PSI-102 Reports SAME Final Science Report, p. 33
- PSI-102 Reports SAME Final Science Report, p. 46
- PSI-102 Reports SAME Final Science Report, p. 48
- PSI-102 Reports SAME Final Science Report, p. 51
- PSI-102 Reports SAME Final Science Report, p. 53
- PSI-102 Reports SAME Final Science Report, p. 54
- PSI-102 Reports SAME Final Science Report, p. 57
- PSI-102 Reports SAME Final Science Report, p. 66
- PSI-102 Science Documents SAME Baseline Concept Description Doc, p. 7
- PSI-102 Science Documents SAME Baseline Concept Description Doc, p. 11
- PSI-102 Science Documents SAME Baseline Concept Description Doc, p. 13
- PSI-102 Science Documents SAME Operations Manual 007, p. 11
- Smoke and Aerosol Measurement Experiment, p. 1 (DOI)
- ISS Destiny Laboratory Smoke Detection Model, p. 1 (DOI)
- Smoke Particle Sizes in Low-Gravity and Implications for Spacecraft Smoke Detector Design, p. 1 (DOI)
- Measurement of Smoke Particle Size under Low-Gravity Conditions, p. 1 (DOI)
- Smoke: Characterization of Smoke Particulate for Spacecraft Fire Detection, Seventh International Microgravity Combustion Workshop, p. 1
- Smoke: Characterization of Smoke Particulate for Spacecraft Fire Detection, p. 1
- Characterization of Nuisance Particulates in the ISS: Space Smoke Aerosols and Lunar Dust Abatement, p. 1 (DOI)
- Combustion Research on the International Space Station, p. 1
- Detection of Smoke from Microgravity Fires, p. 1
- A Research Plan for Fire Prevention, Detection and Suppression in Crewed Exploration Systems, p. 1 (DOI)
- Pyrolysis Smoke Generated Under Low-Gravity Conditions, p. 1 (DOI)
- Smoke Characterization and Feasibility of the Moment Method for Spacecraft Fire Detection, p. 1 (DOI)
- Evaluation of spacecraft smoke detector performance in the low-gravity environment, p. 1 (DOI)
- The Microgravity Science Glovebox (MSG), a Resource for Gravity-Dependent Phenomena Research on the International Space Station (ISS), p. 1 (DOI)
- AN OVERVIEW OF THE MICROGRAVITY SCIENCE GLOVEBOX (MSG) FACILITY, AND THE GRAVITY-DEPENDENT PHENOMENARESEARCH PERFORMED IN THE MSG ON THE INTERNATIONAL SPACE STATION (ISS), p. 1